Robbie Withey's defection signals growing discontent within the Conservatives.
Topics covered
In a significant political shift, Robbie Withey, an Aberdeenshire councillor, has announced his support for Nigel Farage’s Reform party ahead of the upcoming Holyrood elections in May 2026. This decision comes on the heels of a tumultuous period for the Scottish Conservatives, marked by multiple defections and internal strife.
Growing discontent within the Conservative ranks
Withey’s pledge to support the Reform party is not an isolated incident; it reflects a broader trend of dissatisfaction among former Conservative members. Three other ex-Tory councillors have already made the switch to Reform, indicating a potential crisis for the party in Scotland.
Withey, who now serves as an independent councillor for Huntly, Strathbogie and Howe of Alford, expressed his intention to discuss priority policies with the Reform party before making a final commitment to join.
Impact of local decisions on party loyalty
The catalyst for Withey’s departure from the Conservative group appears to be the controversial decision to close several local nurseries, including those in Glass, Huntly, Crossroads, and Ballogie. This move has sparked outrage among constituents and has been a significant factor in Withey’s decision to leave the party. He stated, “I will certainly be supporting them at next year’s Scottish elections,” highlighting his disillusionment with the current Conservative leadership.
Internal conflicts and leadership challenges
The Scottish Conservatives are grappling with internal conflicts that have further weakened their position. Gillian Owen, the former group leader, resigned amid damaging infighting, which included her sending derogatory messages about fellow party members. This turmoil has left the party vulnerable, as evidenced by the recent defection of Ellon councillor John Crawley, who cited feeling “let down by so many broken promises.”
Former leader Mark Findlater’s departure last October, along with ex-Tory Laurie Carnie’s shift to independent status, underscores the growing instability within the party. Scottish Tory leader Russell Findlay has acknowledged the disillusionment among voters, stating, “What I understand is why people, voters in Scotland and across the United Kingdom, feel disillusioned.” He emphasized the need for the Conservatives to rebuild trust and present a coherent alternative to the left-wing consensus at Holyrood.
As the political landscape in Scotland continues to evolve, the rise of the Reform party and the challenges faced by the Conservatives may reshape the dynamics of the upcoming elections. With Withey’s support, the Reform party could gain traction among disenchanted voters seeking a new direction in Scottish politics.
