Scott Arthur MP Proposes Comprehensive Firework Restrictions in Edinburgh

Edinburgh MP Scott Arthur advocates for a single firework control zone covering the entire city to enhance safety and reduce anti-social behavior.

In a bid to enhance public safety and reduce anti-social behavior, Edinburgh MP Scott Arthur has proposed the implementation of a single, city-wide firework control zone (FCZ) instead of the current patchwork of 14 designated areas. This initiative aims to streamline regulations and ensure a safer environment for residents and emergency services during Bonfire Night celebrations.

The current system, which divides Edinburgh into 14 separate FCZs, has been in place since last year. These zones prohibit the use of fireworks anywhere within their boundaries, including private property. The approach has been credited with contributing to a significant reduction in violence and incidents during last year’s Bonfire Night, compared to the “mayhem” of previous years when police, firefighters, and bus drivers faced attacks.

The Case for a Unified Firework Control Zone

Dr. Arthur, Labour MP for Edinburgh South West, argues that a single FCZ covering the entire city would be more effective and easier to manage. “Edinburgh only really needs one firework control zone, and it should cover the whole city.

I think that’s what people want. It makes sense just to get on with it,” he stated. He emphasized that while FCZs are not a panacea, they are a valuable tool in combating anti-social behavior.

The legislation governing FCZs requires evidence to justify restrictions in each area. Dr. Arthur noted that this requirement can be cumbersome, but he believes the benefits of a city-wide approach outweigh the administrative challenges. “Some people argue it’s removing their freedoms and say we are killjoys, but I think broadly speaking we’re in a place now where people have just had enough and they want to be safe and they want the emergency services to be safe,” he added.

Community Involvement and Retailer Engagement

Communities were invited to apply for FCZ status in their local areas, highlighting concerns such as the misuse of fireworks, anti-social behavior, and the need to protect vulnerable residents, including older people and pets. The council’s culture and communities committee approved 14 FCZs for this year, from October 30 until November 8, which is five more than in 2026.

Last year, Dr. Arthur successfully campaigned to persuade major retailers in his constituency not to sell fireworks. This effort, along with similar actions by other MPs, resulted in a dramatic reduction in the number of traders selling fireworks in Edinburgh. In 2026, there were 33 traders, but last year only two. Dr. Arthur plans to write to retailers again soon to ensure they do not resume selling fireworks.

“One store manager in Edinburgh told me they still had people who came into the store looking for fireworks and were disappointed they couldn’t get them. But broadly the staff thought it was the right thing not to be selling them,” he said. He also hopes that other ideas, such as organized firework displays and alternative activities for young people, will be explored to further combat anti-social behavior.

Support from Local Authorities

Culture and communities convener Margaret Graham expressed support for the current approach, stating that fireworks can have a significant impact on vulnerable people and pets. “Firework Control Zones are an important part of our wider approach to keeping communities safe during Bonfire Night and reduce the disruption that fireworks can cause,” she said. She noted that while a city-wide FCZ has not been ruled out for the future, feedback from residents and community groups indicates that the current approach has been effective.

The new fireworks control zones for this year will cover parts of Wester Hailes, West Pilton, Lochend, Stenhouse/Gaskell Street, and Liberton Grange. The previous zones, which will be in force again, include Balerno, Calton Hill, Niddrie, Seafield, Corstorphine, Longstone, Moredun, Sighthill/Broomhouse, and Gracemount (now redesignated as The Murrays).

As Edinburgh prepares for Bonfire Night, the debate over the most effective way to manage firework use continues. With the support of local authorities and community groups, the city aims to ensure a safer and more enjoyable celebration for all residents.