×
google news

Credibility clause for slavery victims sparks outcry in UK bill

Survivors fear new UK law could weaponise trauma against them.

Credibility clause for slavery victims sparks outcry in UK bill

The Immigration and Asylum Bill cleared its final stage in the House of Commons on Tuesday, moving toward the House of Lords for further scrutiny. Among its many provisions, a new paragraph, often referred to as Clause 41, requires officials to view certain factors as damaging to a claimant’s credibility.

These factors include delayed reporting, inconsistencies in a survivor’s narrative, and striking similarities to another person’s account. While the government frames the measure as a safeguard against fraudulent claims, critics argue it mirrors the behavioural patterns of genuine modern slavery victims.

Expert and survivor backlash against the credibility clause

Independent anti-slavery commissioner Eleanor Lyons warned that the law could undermine the very foundations of survivor testimony. She explained that trauma often distorts memory, causing victims to disclose their experiences years after the abuse and to present narratives that appear inconsistent.

Lyons told the Press Association, “It is appalling that the Government is instead introducing new requirements in law that could undermine survivors’ credibility simply because time has passed since their exploitation, because there are inconsistencies in their accounts, or because their experiences are similar to those of other victims.”

One survivor, identified only as Isabella, recounted her ordeal under a late billionaire whose name has become synonymous with high-profile trafficking cases. The Home Office has officially recognized her as a modern-slavery victim. Isabella argued that the clause would turn “the recognised consequences of trafficking into statutory reasons to doubt their credibility.” She added that the very evidence used to prove an organised trafficking network (delayed disclosure, trauma-related inconsistencies, and parallel testimonies) would be wielded against the victims themselves.

Parliamentary debate and cross-party amendment proposals

During the Commons debate, several MPs rallied behind amendments aimed at stripping the contentious language from the bill. SNP MP Pete Wishart introduced a proposal to delete the clause outright, gaining support from Labour representatives Tonia Antoniazzi, Brian Leishman, and a slate of Green Party members including Sian Berry and Adrian Ramsay. Labour former education minister Olivia Bailey also tabled a child-focused amendment, requesting that any inconsistencies in a youngster’s statement not be used to undermine their protection.

In addition to the credibility provisions, the bill contains measures that reduce the period of leave for recognized refugees from five years to two-and-half years and streamline the removal process for failed asylum seekers. Home Office minister Anna Turley defended the legislation, praising clauses that strengthen the national referral mechanism for children and impose greater reporting duties on businesses regarding modern-slavery supply-chain risks. She stated, “We are doing a huge amount to support victims of modern slavery, and I think that ought to be recognition of how far we’ve come and the leadership we show in this country.”

Despite the government’s defence, a minority of Labour MPs expressed deep concern. Bell Ribeiro-Addy warned that settlement could be “bought and flogged to the highest bidder” under the bill’s provisions, while Apsana Begum described the legislation as an “utter betrayal” of vulnerable migrants. The dissenting group, though limited in number, highlighted the risk that the credibility test could silence victims by adding a bureaucratic hurdle to an already fraught reporting process.

Potential impact on victims and next legislative steps

If enacted, the credibility clause could force decision-makers to treat any delay in reporting as a negative factor unless they can demonstrate “good reasons.” However, the bill does not define what constitutes a good reason, leaving officials with considerable discretion. Isabella warned that this ambiguity would enable a “double coercion” effect: first, traffickers’ intimidation and systemic failures would deter disclosure; second, once a survivor finally speaks out, the law would automatically cast doubt on their account.

The Commons vote recorded a majority of 290-94 in favour of the bill, sending it to the Lords for further examination. While the government touts the reforms as the “most significant migration reforms of modern times,” the controversy surrounding the credibility clause underscores a broader tension between immigration control and the protection of modern-slavery survivors. The outcome of the forthcoming Lords debate, combined with the cross-party amendments already tabled, will determine whether the clause survives or is stripped from the final text.


Contacts:
Clara Hargreaves

Clara Hargreaves writes about Lifestyle, People, Art and design, Travel in Italy, Business and News for newshub.co.uk. She delivers consumer-facing features, cultural profiles, practical travel guides and business analysis, pairing clear reporting with accessible insight to help readers plan, understand and enjoy these topics.