Plans to transform historic church into a community hub face backlash from heritage advocates.
Topics covered
A significant debate has erupted over the proposed removal of pews from St Nicholas Kirk in Aberdeen, as the new owners, Edinburgh Palette, aim to revitalize the historic site. The church, which has been a landmark in the city center, was mothballed by the Church of Scotland before being taken over by Edinburgh Palette last summer.
Their vision includes transforming the West Kirk section into a vibrant tourist destination, showcasing over 100 historical artifacts and serving as a community space for music performances and gatherings.
Plans for modernization and community engagement
To achieve this ambitious vision, Edinburgh Palette has outlined several necessary changes to the ancient site, including the controversial removal of rows of pews that they argue occupy most of the available space.
The organization has submitted a listed building consent application to Aberdeen City Council, detailing plans to upgrade old doors to meet modern fire regulations and install CCTV for security. Additionally, they propose enhancing the existing heating and lighting systems, including the installation of a striking ‘Halo chandelier’.
Heritage concerns and community opposition
However, the proposal has faced significant opposition from various community members and heritage advocates. Arthur Winfield, project leader of the Open Space Trust, which owns the other half of the church, has expressed deep concern over the potential loss of the pews, describing St Nicholas Kirk as one of the few remaining examples of an unaltered 18th-century church interior in Scotland. In a letter of objection, he emphasized that removing the pews would irreparably damage the church’s heritage, stating, “Once heritage is destroyed, it cannot be replaced.” Winfield’s sentiments are echoed by other community members who view the pews as integral to the church’s historical significance.
Support for the transformation
Despite the opposition, there are voices in favor of the proposed changes. The Aberdeen and District Organists Association has supported the plans, arguing that removing some pews would create a dedicated performance area, enhancing the church’s functionality as a venue for social events. Internationally-acclaimed organist Kamil Mika has also weighed in, suggesting that the removal of pews deemed “of secondary importance” would not significantly alter the church’s historic character and could improve the building’s acoustics, making it more suitable for concerts and hymn singing.
As the planning committee of Aberdeen City Council prepares to make a decision on the proposals, the community remains divided. The outcome will not only determine the future of St Nicholas Kirk but also reflect the ongoing tension between preserving heritage and adapting historical sites for modern use. The council’s planning chiefs have recommended approval of the pew removal to facilitate the building’s conversion for its new purpose, but the final decision is yet to be made.
