A passionate campaign aims to save two cherished community facilities in Edinburgh's Sighthill neighborhood from potential demolition
The Sighthill community in Edinburgh is rallying to save two of its most valued institutions from potential demolition. A petition has been launched urging the City of Edinburgh Council to repair rather than demolish the Calderglen Early Years Centrewhich was abruptly closed in March due to safety concerns.
The campaign also seeks to protect the neighboring Gate 55 community centrewhich faces an uncertain future.
The Calderglen nurserywhich has served 64 children since its establishment in 1972, was closed on March 2 following discoveries of significant roof damage. A small ceiling collapse and substantial water leaks in early February raised serious concerns about the building’s long-term safety.
While parents received notice of a ‘permanent’ closure, council reports later clarified this was intended as a temporary measure for the remainder of the season.
The Community’s Heartfelt Appeal
Petition organizers have expressed deep concern about the potential loss of these community assets.
‘To see these buildings be destroyed would be devastating for the community,’ they stated. The facilities have provided ‘a lot of joy and resources’ to Sighthill residents over the years, and their removal would place additional strain on surrounding nurseries and community centers.
The petition highlights several key points in its appeal to councilors. First, it emphasizes that there was no official proposal or consultation regarding the closure of Calderglen. The organizers argue that repairing the facility would be a more beneficial solution than demolition. They also suggest that if repairs are not feasible, the nursery could temporarily relocate to the Gate 55 centre while a long-term plan is developed.
One of the nursery’s most attractive features, according to the petition, is its outdoor areas, which have been a major draw for families in the area. The loss of these spaces would be particularly felt by the community.
The Council’s Considerations
The council is currently evaluating the petition alongside other options for early years investment in the area. A report presented to councilors suggests that while the initial closure was intended to be temporary, it would be ‘prudent’ to explore alternative solutions. The cost of replacing the nursery’s damaged roof is estimated at £352,000, with repairs potentially taking up to 20 weeks to complete.
The report also indicates that a business case for the ‘best value option’ to meet future early years demand in the area will be presented at a September education committee meeting. This case will likely consider factors such as the cost of repairs versus demolition, the availability of alternative facilities, and the long-term needs of the community.
One point of uncertainty in the community’s campaign is whether there has been any official proposal to demolish the Gate 55 centre. The Local Democracy Reporting Service has not found any public announcement regarding the centre’s potential demolition, leaving its future somewhat unclear.
The Path Forward
As the community awaits the council’s decision, the petition continues to gain support from residents who value these important facilities. The campaign highlights the broader issue of maintaining and investing in community resources, particularly in areas where such services may already be limited.
The outcome of this petition could set a precedent for how the council approaches the preservation of community buildings in the future. Whether through repair, relocation, or alternative solutions, the Sighthill community hopes to see these valued institutions continue to serve their neighborhood for years to come.
