Referee's failure to award a free-kick raises questions in Liverpool vs Everton match

Topics covered
The recent Merseyside derby between Liverpool and Everton has ignited a firestorm of debate surrounding referee Michael Oliver’s decisions during the match. A pivotal moment occurred when Liverpool’s Mohamed Salah was brought down by Everton midfielder Carlos Alcaraz, yet no free-kick was awarded.
This incident, occurring just minutes before Everton equalized, has left fans and analysts alike questioning the officiating standards in the Premier League.
Controversial non-call raises eyebrows
Keith Hackett, the former chief of the Professional Game Match Officials Limited (PGMOL), expressed his bewilderment over Oliver’s failure to award a free-kick in a dangerous area.
According to Hackett, it was “difficult to understand” how such a clear foul went unpunished, especially given the context of the match. The decision not only affected the immediate outcome but also had significant implications for Liverpool’s title aspirations.
Oliver’s recent challenges and scrutiny
Michael Oliver has faced intense scrutiny in recent weeks, particularly following the FA’s decision to overturn his red card for Arsenal’s Myles Lewis-Skelly. This incident has led to a wave of criticism from fans, with many questioning his ability to manage high-stakes matches effectively. Despite this, Hackett noted that Oliver had worked diligently to maintain control during the heated Merseyside derby, which saw multiple players sent off after the final whistle.
Impact on Liverpool’s title race
As the match unfolded, Liverpool appeared to be on the verge of securing a crucial victory, leading 2-1 as stoppage time approached. However, James Tarkowski’s stunning equalizer in the 98th minute not only salvaged a point for Everton but also raised concerns about Liverpool’s morale heading into the final stretch of the season. With the title race heating up, the missed opportunity to extend their lead over Arsenal could prove costly for the Reds.
As Liverpool prepares to regroup, the focus will be on how they respond to this setback. With Arsenal facing their own challenges, including injuries to key players, the race for the Premier League crown remains wide open. The fallout from the Merseyside derby will undoubtedly linger, as fans and pundits alike continue to dissect the implications of Oliver’s controversial decisions.