Milburn’s report urges a phased reduction in National Insurance for 21‑24‑year‑olds and a reshuffle of youth benefits, sparking debate over cost and effectiveness.

The United Kingdom faces a persistent pool of young people who are not in work, education or training: the so-called Neets. Official figures show almost one million individuals aged 16 to 24 fall into this category, costing taxpayers around £22 billion each year.
The pressure to convert this group into productive contributors has intensified, prompting the government to consider structural changes.
Milburn’s blueprint for National Insurance relief
Former Labour minister Alan Milburn has completed a year-long review that will be released on Tuesday.
Central to the report is a proposal to lower employer National Insurance (NI) contributions for workers aged 21 to 24. The plan calls for a gradual reduction over five years, beginning with sectors hit hardest by labour shortages: retail and hospitality.
The threshold at which employers start paying NI for this age bracket would rise from £5,000 to £10,000, effectively halving the charge once fully implemented.
Fiscal calculations and timing
Research from the Resolution Foundation estimates that an immediate, across-the-board abolition of NI for 21-24-year-olds would cost roughly £5.1 billion. Milburn cautions that, given the current fiscal position, such a sweeping cut is not the most efficient use of public funds. He therefore recommends that the threshold increase be introduced only when “fiscal conditions allow”, allowing the government to spread the expense across several budget cycles.
Reforming benefits for under-25s
The review does not stop at tax policy. It also suggests a redesign of the benefits system for young people. Under-25s would lose entitlement to the health component of UK-wide Universal Credit and the Personal Independence Payment (PIP). In exchange, the report calls for a legally binding “opportunity guarantee” that obliges authorities to provide a job, apprenticeship, training place or health support to every eligible young person. Those who refuse the offered assistance could see their benefits withdrawn.
Wider policy backdrop
The NI proposal arrives after the current administration, led by Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer, raised employer NI rates. Milburn argues that the recent rise did not cause the surge in Neets, but it does add to the cost burden on businesses hiring young staff. At the same time, Chancellor John Healey announced a modest increase in the national minimum wage: from £10.85 to £11.27 for 18-20-year-olds and from £12.71 to £13.21 for those 21 and older, a move Milburn describes as understandable but financially demanding.
Political responses and complementary schemes
Shadow work and pensions secretary Helen Whately dismissed the tax proposal as unnecessary, urging the government to “just stop doing the taxing”. Conversely, Work and Pensions Secretary Pat McFadden announced an extension of the subsidised jobs guarantee for 18-24-year-olds claiming Universal Credit, reducing the qualifying period from 18 months to 12 months and making the scheme available across England, Scotland and Wales.
Challenges ahead
Milburn acknowledges that skill development is futile without available jobs, emphasizing that any benefit cuts must be paired with genuine employment opportunities. He also notes that many young workers enter the labour market with mental-health issues such as anxiety or ADHD, increasing the cost burden on small businesses. The report therefore supports wage subsidies to offset these extra expenses.
The success of the proposed NI reduction and benefits overhaul will depend on the government’s ability to balance immediate fiscal pressure with long-term reductions in the youth welfare bill. If implemented gradually, the measures could reshape the cost structure for hiring young staff while redirecting £22 billion of annual support toward active employment programmes.

