New league structure aims to better reflect Scotland's geography and club distribution
Topics covered
Plans are underway to restructure tier five of the Scottish football pyramid, as reported by the Press and Journal. The proposal aims to introduce a third league beneath the Scottish Professional Football League (SPFL), which sources suggest would better reflect the geographical distribution of clubs across Scotland.
Understanding the proposed league structure
Currently, the Breedon Highland League and Lowland League operate below League Two. The new proposal suggests the creation of a 16-team Lowland League East and a 16-team Lowland League West, which would coexist with the Highland League at tier five.
This restructuring would allow for a more balanced representation of clubs across different regions, addressing the significant travel distances that clubs currently face.
The proposed setup would also involve two divisions at tier six feeding into these three leagues. Clubs from the North Region Juniors and North Caledonian League could gain promotion to the Highland League, provided they meet the necessary licensing criteria. Similarly, teams from the Midlands League and East of Scotland League would have the opportunity to advance into the new Lowland League East, while clubs from the West of Scotland League and South of Scotland League could move into the Lowland League West.
Geographical considerations and club representation
The rationale behind this proposed change is largely geographical. The distances that clubs in the Highland League must travel can be daunting, with some clubs, like Brechin City, facing significant travel burdens. The disparity in population and club distribution between the Lowland and Highland League areas is notable, with a ratio of three to one. By introducing a third tier at this level, the proposal aims to acknowledge and accommodate these geographical realities.
Furthermore, the restructuring would not alter the overall governance of Scottish football. The Lowland League would continue to oversee the East and West leagues, ensuring that the Scottish Football Association (SFA) representation remains unchanged. The SPFL would also remain unaffected, with the pyramid play-off final continuing as it currently stands.
Next steps and potential implementation
The SFA, SPFL, and all tier six leagues are reportedly aware of the proposal, and a consultation process is currently in progress. Both the Highland and Lowland Leagues are believed to support the initiative strongly. A meeting with the SPFL is scheduled for later this month, while the SFA’s pyramid working group is set to discuss the plans in early April.
If the pyramid working group approves the proposal, it will be presented to the SFA’s executive board for final approval. Should the plan proceed as intended, the new league structure could be implemented in time for the next season, significantly altering the landscape of Scottish football.
In summary, the proposed restructuring of tier five in the Scottish football pyramid aims to enhance competition and better reflect the geographical distribution of clubs. By introducing a third league, the initiative seeks to alleviate travel burdens and create a more equitable playing field for clubs across Scotland.
